Guides / Fixed Fractional vs. Fixed Lot Sizing
Two sizing rules, very different drawdown mathFixed fractional vs. fixed lot: position sizing under drawdown.
Two traders can both say they "risk 1% per trade" and mean two different things. One recalculates that 1% every trade off current equity. The other picked a lot size once and keeps using it. They behave the same when the account is flat, and completely differently the moment it isn't.
Quick answer: fixed fractional sizing risks a constant percentage of your current equity on every trade, so position size shrinks in a drawdown and grows as the account recovers. Fixed lot sizing trades the same lot size every time regardless of what equity is doing. The dollar risk per trade stays flat under fixed lot, but as a percentage of a shrinking account, that flat dollar amount gets larger with every loss.
What "fixed fractional" and "fixed lot" each actually mean
Fixed fractional sizing risks a set percentage of whatever your equity is right now. If the rule is "risk 1% per trade," the dollar amount at risk is recalculated before every single trade: 1% of $10,000 is $100, but after a string of losses brings equity to $9,000, the next trade only risks $90. The position size (lots, contracts, whatever unit you trade in) is derived from that dollar figure and your stop distance, so it moves with the account.
Fixed lot sizing skips that recalculation. You decide on a lot size (say, 1 standard lot per trade) and trade that same size regardless of what the account did last week. The dollar amount at risk per trade is set by the lot size and your stop distance, not by equity. It doesn't move until you decide to change it.
Both are legitimate, widely used approaches. The difference only becomes visible once equity starts moving, and it moves in opposite directions depending on whether the account is up or down.
Why fixed lot risk, as a percent of equity, drifts during a drawdown
Risk as a percentage of the account is always this ratio:
Under fixed fractional sizing, the numerator and the denominator move together by design: the dollar amount is defined as a percentage of equity, so the ratio stays pinned at whatever percentage you set. Under fixed lot sizing, the numerator is frozen (same lot size, same stop distance, same dollar risk) while the denominator shrinks every time a trade loses. A constant number divided by a shrinking number only goes one way: up. That's the entire mechanism. It isn't a bug in any platform or broker; it's arithmetic, and it applies regardless of instrument, leverage, or strategy.
Watching 1% quietly become 1.25% without changing anything
Example, with clean round numbers, not a real backtest. Take a $10,000 account trading 1 standard lot per position, with a stop distance that puts $100 at risk on every trade. At the starting balance, that's exactly 1% of equity. Now run a losing stretch and watch what the same $100 risk represents as a percentage of what's left:
- Equity $10,000 → risk $100 → 1.00% of equity
- 5 losses, equity $9,500 → risk still $100 → 1.05% of equity
- 10 losses, equity $9,000 → risk still $100 → 1.11% of equity
- 15 losses, equity $8,500 → risk still $100 → 1.18% of equity
- 20 losses, equity $8,000 → risk still $100 → 1.25% of equity
Nobody changed a setting. The lot size never moved. But the account is now risking a quarter more of its remaining equity per trade than it was at the start, right in the middle of a losing stretch, which is exactly when that extra exposure is least welcome. Run the same losing stretch under fixed fractional sizing instead: after the first $100 loss, equity is $9,900, so the next trade risks 1% of that: $99, not $100. The dollar amount shrinks a little every time, but the percentage never leaves 1%. The two methods produce the same starting trade and increasingly different trades after that.
Fixed fractional is the usual answer for risk-of-ruin math, but it isn't free
Classic risk-of-ruin formulas and prop-firm drawdown-limit math generally assume you're risking a constant percentage of current equity, not a constant dollar amount. That assumption is what keeps the probability of blowing through a drawdown limit bounded and calculable: if a firm's rule is "disabled at 10% below peak balance," sizing your risk as a percentage of current equity keeps your exposure proportional to however much cushion you actually have left, instead of staying flat while the cushion disappears. It's the same reason fixed fractional sizing is the default assumption behind most published risk-of-ruin tables.
That protection has a cost, and it's psychological rather than mathematical. Fixed fractional sizing shrinks your position right after you've already lost money, exactly when a trader wants to "make it back" and exactly when trusting a system that's telling you to trade smaller feels hardest. It also means your recovery is slower in dollar terms: clawing back from a drawdown with progressively smaller position sizes takes longer than clawing back with the same size you lost it at. Fixed fractional protects the account; it doesn't make losing streaks comfortable.
The mistakes that show up when the two get mixed together
- Switching from fixed lot to fixed fractional (or back) mid-strategy without re-testing: the equity curve, max drawdown, and risk-of-ruin numbers from the old method don't carry over to the new one.
- Assuming fixed lot sizing is "simpler, so it must be safer." Simpler to calculate, yes. Safer is a separate question, and the worked example above is the reason it isn't automatically true.
- Backtesting with fixed fractional sizing (which compounds position size as equity grows or shrinks) and then trading the live account fixed lot. The backtested drawdown and recovery numbers assume a sizing method you aren't actually using.
- Calling a position "1% risk" out of habit, based on what it was when the account was at its high-water mark, without rechecking what it actually represents after a drawdown.
Match your live sizing to whatever your backtest assumed
Pick the method deliberately, not by default. If your backtest or risk-of-ruin math assumes a constant percentage of equity, your live sizing needs to recalculate position size from current equity before every trade, not just when you remember to. If you'd rather trade fixed lot for simplicity, that's a legitimate choice too, but build in a check: recalculate what your flat dollar risk actually represents as a percentage of equity on a regular schedule, and resize manually when it's drifted further than you're comfortable with. Either way, the number that matters is the one in the formula above, not the lot size you started with.
Allocate sizes positions across your strategies from current equity, not a lot size set once and forgotten.
Open AllocateRelated free calculators: Position Size Calculator · Compounding Calculator